Friday, August 27, 2010
The political record of the independent MPs by By Graham Matthews
Unlike Wilkie, whose most recent affiliation was with the Greens, the three established independents, Tony Windsor and Rob Oakeshott from NSW and Bob Katter from Queensland, came out of the National Party. While they have been described by the media as conservative independents, on a raft of issues they are more progressive than either of the major parties.
Katter is perhaps the most ideological of the three independents. On his website he describes his motivation for leaving the National Party, which party he represented in state and federal parliaments for 27 years. Katter left the Nationals and ran as an independent in 2001, “due to his disenchantment with economic rationality that he felt the National Party was adopting”.
In Parliament, Katter opposed the sale of Telstra in 2003 and again in 2005. He opposed the sale of Medibank Private in 2006 and in that speech lamented the privatisation of the Commonwealth Bank, Qantas and other state assets. “So whether it is the railways, Qantas or the banks, we got a dreadful deal out of privatisation. If Medibank Private is sold, I do not doubt for a moment that we will get the same sort of deal,” he said on November 2, 2006.
No one could accuse Katter of being an environmentalist. A noted climate sceptic, Katter also opposes legislation to protect the environment, and grant Indigenous people native title. “Rural recreation, fishing, hunting, trail riding and camping have all been dramatically curtailed by the environmental push. Property rights were undermined by Mabo and Biodiversity Legislation,” he says on his website.
Nevertheless Katter has spoken publicly against the Northern Territory Emergency Intervention. “The fact that they've had all alcohol taken off them, all pornography taken off them and they're going to have their money taken off them and handed to them - like they were little children - through a trust fund sounds good but in reality it is the most dreadful, discriminatory, repressive laws,” Katter told SBS TV's Living Black program on September 10 2008.
Tony Windsor, independent MP for New England, has also stated his opposition to the NT Intervention. “One of the reasons why I was opposed to the intervention in the Northern Territory is that a blanket approach such as that does not recognise the flexibility that is required,” he told Parliament on February 19 2008. He concluded his speech by calling for the reinstatement of the permit system.
Unlike Katter, Windsor accepts the science of climate change. “I believe that there is human induced climate change. I believe it is something that we should do something about. I am not one of the sceptics,” he told Parliament on October 28 2009.
However, Windsor also opposed federal Labor's Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme, arguing that the target of 5% reductions was “nonsense” and that, “It does nothing about the issue. It puts in place an economic structure which will achieve not much more than people stopping cleaning their shoes, in terms of saving emissions.”
Windsor also opposed the sale of Telstra in 2002 and the bill to sell the Snowy Mountains Hydro-electricity scheme in 2006. “It was only the two independents ...who divided the parliament to vote against the sale as the Coalition and Labor parties crammed together to vote for its sale as they had done in the NSW and Victorian parliaments”, he said in a press release on August 5 this year.
The newest of the three independents, Oakeshott, is a former National turned independent in the NSW state parliament, who won the federal seat of Lyne in a bi-election when former National Party leader Mark Vaile retired in 2008. While a former shadow minister for the National Party in state parliament, Oakeshott has taken some progressive stands.
Oakeshott has championed renewable energy. He has criticised the Labor government for “browning down” renewable energy legislation, and demanded a national renewable energy feed-in tariff, to encourage investment, in speeches to Parliament in August 2009.
Oakeshott has voiced some support for justice for Indigenous people seeking Naive Title to land, and has noted the objections of the Australian Council for Social Service for the welfare quarantining aspects of the NT intervention. However, unlike Windsor and Katter, he has not publicly opposed it.
The strongest link between the three independents, all of whom came to politics through the National Party, is their rejection of that party. Styling themselves as defenders of the interests of farmers, small business and workers in the country, they oppose what they see as the destruction of services and the threat of deregulation and globalisation.
Whichever major party the independents ultimately decide to support to form a minority government, one thing is certain. On a wide range of issues, from climate change, to Indigenous rights, to economic policy, the independents are objectively to the left of both major parties. That will certainly make for an interesting term of Parliament.
Green Left Weekly 25-8-10